More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
Imagine watching a podcast unravel live: two famous YouTubers, co-hosts and family by marriage, explode into an argument so raw you can see the comment section melting down in real time. Suddenly, one storms out, announces they’re quitting, and the internet splits into warring camps overnight. That’s exactly what happened when Trisha Paytas walked out on Ethan Klein and the “Frenemies” podcast, tearing apart one of the internet’s most-watched collaborations in the space of a single, fiery episode.
Let’s break down exactly who’s involved and how things spiraled out of control. Ethan Klein is the face of H3H3 Productions, a channel that built its reputation on reaction videos and commentary, often targeting other online personalities. Trisha Paytas is one of the most notorious and unpredictable figures on YouTube—a creator whose career spans music videos, mukbangs, and viral controversies, with millions of subscribers and views. Their paths first crossed publicly in May 2019, when Ethan released a video calling out influencers, including Trisha, for photoshopping their Instagram photos. Trisha hit back hard, calling Ethan, quote, “a disgusting piece of s***.”
Despite that rocky start, by October 2019, Trisha actually appeared on the H3 Podcast to hash things out. The chemistry was weirdly electric. Fans watched as enemies became frenemies, trading insults, confessions, and jokes. That initial tension was the spark for something neither of them could have predicted: a joint show. On September 15, 2020, they launched “Frenemies.” The premise was simple but volatile—take two of YouTube’s most unfiltered voices, put them together for long-form, no-holds-barred conversations, and let the drama play out for all to see.
The show was an instant hit. Over 39 episodes, Ethan and Trisha covered everything from internet scandals to their own therapy sessions. “Frenemies” regularly pulled in hundreds of thousands of views per episode, sometimes over a million. The duo’s dynamic was explosive: Trisha’s unpredictability and raw honesty clashed with Ethan’s deadpan humor and attempts at structure. Fans described it as “comfort chaos.” But beneath the laughs and viral clips, simmering tensions kept boiling closer to the surface.
The breaking point came on June 8, 2021. During a taping, a seemingly routine disagreement about the show’s production turned into a full-blown showdown. The argument centered on creative control and money: who got to decide what happened in the show, and how revenue from sponsorships and YouTube ad dollars was split. Trisha accused Ethan of shutting her out of decisions and not giving her enough say in the hiring of crew. Ethan tried to explain the business side, but Trisha felt stonewalled. On air, Trisha announced she was quitting. The episode ended with Trisha leaving the set.
Within hours, Trisha posted on social media confirming her departure. Ethan took to his own platforms, saying, “I’m honestly gutted over this whole thing, Trisha’s decision to leave ‘Frenemies’ is beyond me.” Fans watched in disbelief as the podcast, one of the highest-performing on YouTube at the time, imploded overnight.
The reaction was immediate and dramatic. Fans picked sides, and accusations flew. Some argued that Trisha had always been the more vulnerable and honest of the two, and that Ethan had tried to control the show from behind the scenes. Others accused Trisha of sabotaging yet another project and being impossible to work with. Subreddits, Discord servers, and Twitter threads exploded with speculation, complicated by the fact that Trisha was also dating Moses Hacmon—Ethan’s brother-in-law, as he’s married to Hila Klein. Suddenly, a professional falling out was also a family feud.
Tensions escalated when, in September 2021, Ethan removed a “Frenemies” episode after Trisha made allegations against a former teacher. When evidence contradicted Trisha’s claims, Ethan pulled the episode from YouTube. Trisha responded by accusing Ethan of sending hate mobs her way, saying she was being blamed unfairly and targeted by Ethan’s audience. The fallout grew personal, with Trisha publicly accusing Ethan of trying to ruin her relationship with Moses. Although both issued legal threats, neither filed lawsuits, and the public fight gradually lost steam without ever landing in court.
Behind the scenes, the drama even affected other projects. In August 2021, Ethan ended his “Families” podcast, which he’d started with Hila Klein, saying the “Frenemies” drama had poisoned the atmosphere and made it impossible to continue. The ripple effect was clear: what started as an internet spat ended up shutting down not just one, but two major shows.
Supporters of Ethan argued that hosting and producing the show involved logistics, contracts, and legal responsibility that Trisha didn’t always acknowledge. Ethan often claimed he was just trying to keep the show running while protecting everyone involved from legal or reputational fallout. Critics of Ethan, meanwhile, said his on-camera behavior could be controlling, that he often talked over Trisha or made jokes at her expense, and that he didn’t appreciate the vulnerability Trisha brought to the show.
On the other side, Trisha’s defenders argued she was continuously undermined, that her ideas for segments or hiring were dismissed, and that her mental health struggles were sometimes played for laughs. Critics of Trisha pointed to her long history of public feuds, dramatic exits, and walking away from collaborations, saying this was just another example of her self-destructive patterns.
As of late 2021, the “Frenemies” podcast remains defunct. No reunion or reboot has happened, and both creators have focused on separate projects. The collaboration is remembered as a brief but intense experiment—thirty-nine episodes that captured the chaos and unpredictability of internet fame and family ties.
One big unresolved question still hangs over the whole saga: will Ethan Klein and Trisha Paytas ever reconcile, either in public or in private, or is this one internet friendship that’s truly been burned to the ground?