More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
If you’ve ever wondered how a pair of fake boots sparked the internet’s most elaborate fandom hoax, you need to hear the story of Goncharov—a film that never existed, except in the hearts and minds of thousands online. Here’s how Tumblr turned a non-existent 1973 mafia movie into its greatest shared obsession, complete with fake posters, imaginary shipping wars, and even a soundtrack composed by dozens of fans.
The Goncharov phenomenon starts in the least cinematic way imaginable: with a Tumblr user, zootycoon, posting a photo of knockoff boots. The label on these boots didn’t say Nike or Adidas. Instead, it described a film “by Matteo JWHJ0715 about the Naples mafia,” allegedly presented by Martin Scorsese, and declared “the greatest mafia movie ever made.” That single photo, uploaded several years before 2022, contained the entire DNA of the Goncharov myth.
But the meme didn’t really take off until August 2020, when Aveline McEntire reblogged the post with a joking reply—“this idiot hasn’t seen Goncharov.” That line became a kind of password, a wink that signaled you were in on the joke. The mechanics of Tumblr’s platform, especially the reblogging feature, let users add more and more layers to the story. Someone else joined in, and soon, Goncharov was being discussed as if it were a lost cinematic classic from the 1970s, directed by Scorsese and starring a cast of Hollywood legends.
Goncharov’s fictional cast and crew quickly congealed into a who’s-who of 1970s cinema. Robert De Niro was said to play Lo Straniero—also known as Goncharov—a Russian hitman and former nightclub manager. Harvey Keitel was his enemy (and sometimes romantic interest) Andrey, a character with homoerotic subtext that fans eagerly dissected. Cybill Shepherd played Katya, Goncharov’s wife, who was rumored to have an affair with Sofia, played by Sophia Loren. Other “cast members” in this imaginary film included Gene Hackman as Valery Michailov, John Cazale as Joseph “Ice Pick Joe” Morelli, Al Pacino as Mario Ambrosini, and even Lynda Carter as Dancer #2. Patchka the cat, an innocent feline, was also credited.
By late November 2022, the meme exploded after a Prague-based artist, Alex Korotchuk, created a lush and detailed poster for the film. The poster listed cast, crew, and character names, anchoring the growing collaborative myth in concrete visuals. That single piece of fan art was shared thousands of times and became the central artifact that everyone referenced, debated, and embellished.
In the collaborative world of Tumblr, Goncharov wasn’t just a meme. It became a fandom with all the trappings of a real film community. Fans created GIFs, wrote hundreds of pieces of erotic fan fiction, and analyzed the non-existent film’s themes as if they were real. One Google Document was opened to catalog and coordinate the shifting details of Goncharov’s plot and characters. As of November 24, 2022, there were over 500 entries for Goncharov on Archive of Our Own, the fan fiction website.
The invented plot of Goncharov was set in Naples, just after the dissolution of the Soviet Union. According to one version outlined by The Washington Post, the film ends with Goncharov betrayed and murdered, along with most of the other characters. Discussions of the film’s “themes” included betrayal, trauma, romance, and the recurring motif of clocks—each detail invented, then dissected as though it had been pored over by generations of film critics and scholars.
The fandom’s creativity extended to music. At least thirty people collaborated to compose a “theme” for Goncharov, available online alongside the fan art and GIF sets. Fan-made content even spread to the platform Letterboxd, where users posted reviews for the nonexistent film until they were eventually removed.
Goncharov’s production history was deliberately inconsistent. In the collaborative fiction, it was produced in 1973, had a troubled production, and never received a proper release. The story became that Goncharov was a “lost film,” which explained its supposed obscurity and allowed Tumblr users to play film historian, piecing together its fate from invented anecdotes.
The meme’s virality was so intense that The New York Times reported Goncharov had become the top trending topic on Tumblr in late November 2022. At the same time, Martin Scorsese himself became the second most popular Tumblr topic. The meme even jumped platforms. Tumblr’s official Twitter account declared that the fictitious film was “ahead of its time.” Lynda Carter joined in, posting about her fictional involvement as Dancer #2. Ryan Reynolds, less than a month after joining Tumblr, posted about his “favorite line” from the film.
One of the most surreal moments came when Scorsese’s daughter posted a TikTok video of a text exchange with her father. She showed him a New York Times article about Goncharov and asked if he’d seen it. Scorsese replied, “Yes. I made that film years ago.”
The mechanics of Tumblr’s reblogging and reply system fueled this explosion of collective storytelling. Jamie Cohen, a professor of media studies at Queens College, explained that Tumblr’s “threaded, stacked replies where people build off each other” made it the perfect platform for Goncharov to go viral. Another Tumblr user, do-you-have-a-flag, described the whole thing as an extension of the site’s “yes, and…” culture, where people take a joke and run with it, expanding the fiction in ways no single person could predict.
The fandom’s energy even spilled over into the world of gaming. On November 25, 2022, Autumn Chen organized a Goncharov “game jam” on itch.io, inspired by a rumor that a nonexistent video game tie-in existed. Fans created games based on the imagined film in less than a week.
Media coverage was breathless and international. Outlets from The Guardian to The Washington Post and NBC News covered the phenomenon, marveling at Tumblr’s ability to generate a sprawling, elaborate fandom out of thin air. Writers like Kelsey Weekman at BuzzFeed and Linda Codega at Gizmodo highlighted the collaborative magic of Tumblr users, who blurred the lines between criticism, parody, and sincere fandom.
The sudden emergence of Goncharov as a fandom also coincided with changes in the wider social media landscape. The meme’s explosion in late 2022 was linked by some writers to Elon Musk’s purchase of Twitter, as more users fled that platform for Tumblr, seeking a creative refuge. This context helped Goncharov become a unifying in-joke, a shared world-building exercise at a moment of internet upheaval.
Goncharov’s fandom wasn’t without debate. Because the “lore” was built by crowdsourced improvisation, details often conflicted. Was Matteo JWHJ0715 the director, or was it Scorsese? Did Katya betray Goncharov, or did she save him? Which ship was canon—Goncharov and Andrey, or Katya and Sofia? Fandom debates raged across hundreds of posts, each as passionate as if the film had actually existed.
One Tumblr user, quoted by The Daily Fix, pinpointed the meme’s uncanny realism: “The Goncharov meme isn’t so much impenetrable to outsiders as it is indistinguishable from business as usual. Goncharov shitposts sound exactly like how film nerds actually sound when discussing a real film which they have not seen, but do not wish to admit they have not seen, so from the uninvolved perspective nothing has changed.”
Author Neil Gaiman repeatedly received questions about Goncharov in his Tumblr inbox and, after a while, publicly asked users to stop.
Just as quickly as it flared up, Goncharov’s meme status entered the folklore of the internet. But the mechanics behind it—a single boot tag, a viral poster, hundreds of fanfics, and a digital game jam—show how a fandom doesn’t need a real story to thrive.
To this day, the public Google Document where fans tracked the evolving canon of Goncharov is still accessible, full of arguments about which version of a scene is true, and which ending is the “real” one.