More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
Founded by Jaime Rogozinski on January 31, 2012, r/WallStreetBets began as a niche corner for self-styled “degenerates” interested in high-risk stock trading. The subreddit quickly grew from a small group into a financial pop-culture juggernaut. By January 2021, r/WallStreetBets had 2.06 million subscribers, and by January 29, 2021, that number had soared to 6.2 million. The appeal lay in the wild, meme-fueled bets, a unique slang, and the promise that anyone with a smartphone and a risky streak could outplay Wall Street professionals.
The spectacle was undeniable. Members shared stories of $10,000 options trades ending in disaster, or a $2,000 deposit swelling to $50,000 before vanishing. The subreddit’s glossary became legendary: “stonks” for stocks, “tendies” for profits, “diamond hands” for holding through losses, and “paper hands” for selling early. Meme Man, the “Stonks guy,” emerged as an unofficial mascot. The culture was irreverent, self-deprecating, and profane. Members called themselves “apes” and “retards,” flipping the script on traditional finance forums and creating a sense of in-group belonging.
But as WallStreetBets gained mainstream attention—especially after the GameStop short squeeze in January 2021—controversies emerged, particularly around gatekeeping. When the GameStop saga exploded, the subreddit’s subscriber count tripled in a single week, fueled in part by Elon Musk’s January 26, 2021 tweet linking to the group after GameStop stock closed up 92.7%. The influx of new users overwhelmed moderation tools and shifted the community dynamic. Longtime members argued that newcomers didn’t understand the subreddit’s culture or the risks involved. Some accused moderators of favoritism, while others felt moderation was either too strict or too lax, leading to confusion and frustration.
The roots of the gatekeeping issue trace back to the early days, when WallStreetBets was a small circle of high-risk traders who often admitted their bets were closer to gambling than investing. By the end of 2016, the subreddit had around 100,000 subscribers. As membership ballooned, the pressure on moderators increased. Moderation, once a matter of enforcing inside jokes, became a challenge of policing millions.
A flashpoint for the controversy came with the GameStop episode. On January 27, 2021, as the stock’s volatility peaked, moderators set the subreddit to private for about an hour to regain control. The move sparked outrage and confusion—some saw it as a necessary defensive measure, while others viewed it as exclusionary. The debate over who belonged intensified as posts were deleted for being off-topic or violating unwritten community codes. In January 2021, the subreddit’s Discord server was banned for “hateful and discriminatory content.” Discord’s staff said the ban was unrelated to the GameStop drama, but r/WallStreetBets moderators reported being overwhelmed by the flood of content and lacking the tools to keep up. The Discord server was eventually reinstated, with Discord staff assisting in moderation, highlighting how quickly moderation could tip into gatekeeping.
The gatekeeping controversy had real-world effects. Jaime Rogozinski, the founder, was removed and banned from moderating in April 2020, shortly after he tried to trademark the WallStreetBets name. In February 2023, Rogozinski sued Reddit for breach of contract and trademark infringement, but the case was dismissed in July 2023. His removal became a rallying point for some long-term members who felt the subreddit had lost its way, while others argued his ouster was necessary to protect the community’s independence.
The influx of celebrities and influential outsiders added another layer of complexity. Martin Shkreli, then CEO of Turing Pharma, posted on the subreddit, betting $20 million on a drug trial and sharing his investment theses. Other high-profile figures like billionaire investor Mark Cuban, YouTube star MrBeast, and Twitch streamer Pokimane—who served as a full moderator in 2020—brought even more attention. Tesla CEO Elon Musk, though not a direct participant, was cited as an influential outsider. Each celebrity’s involvement raised questions: Were they genuine participants or outsiders capitalizing on the hype? And who had the authority to decide?
The stakes of moderation and gatekeeping became clear during incidents involving trading exploits. In January 2019, a user named u/1R0NYMAN sold a box spread aiming for a $40,000–$50,000 gain but quickly lost $60,000. Robinhood, the brokerage most used by WallStreetBets members, responded by banning box spreads entirely. In November 2019, another user, u/ControlTheNarrative, found a bug in Robinhood’s platform that allowed him to leverage a $2,000 deposit up to roughly $50,000, ultimately losing $46,000. When these exploits became public, some users celebrated the audacity, while others called for tighter controls and moderation.
During the height of the GameStop squeeze, review-bombing campaigns targeted Robinhood’s app, dropping its rating to one star. Google intervened by deleting negative reviews, raising the rating to 2.2. Every moderation decision—who could post, what could be shared, which voices were amplified—became fodder for accusations of gatekeeping.
Some critics argue that gatekeeping is unfair to new members drawn in by media hype. With millions of subscribers, the odds of anyone fitting the original mold are slim. The language, humor, and risk appetite that defined WallStreetBets in 2012 can be baffling or alienating for newcomers. Deleting posts or banning users for not “getting it” may lock out voices who could contribute new perspectives or challenge risky groupthink. Defenders of the status quo say that without strong moderation, the unique culture that made WallStreetBets famous would be diluted beyond recognition.
The community continues to debate its boundaries. Should WallStreetBets be a free-for-all where any trading story gets a stage, or should it enforce a tighter vision, with moderators acting as gatekeepers for tone, language, and trading strategy? This debate reflects larger questions about internet culture: What happens when a small, self-selecting group becomes a mass movement overnight? Can any online community scale without losing its identity?
On January 24, 2021, r/WallStreetBets had 2.06 million subscribers. By January 29, it had reached 6.2 million.