More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
Here’s a question: What happens when millions of strangers come together online to judge each other’s most personal, messy moments—and start to feel like they know one another? Welcome to the world of r/AmItheAsshole, where the lines between honest advice, entertainment, and one-sided intimacy blur in ways that can be both fascinating and unsettling.
r/AmItheAsshole—known as AITA—was created on June 8, 2013 by Marc Beaulac, who wanted to settle a real-life debate about whether he’d been inappropriately mansplaining at work. Since then, AITA has exploded into one of Reddit’s largest communities, boasting 24 million members as of March 2025—more people than live in Australia. That sheer scale means that every day, thousands of people post anonymously about conflicts with partners, family, friends, and coworkers, looking for the judgment of total strangers. Each post asks a variation on the same question: “AITA for what I did?” The community weighs in using labels like YTA (you’re the asshole), NTA (not the asshole), ESH (everyone sucks here), or NAH (no assholes here).
It’s easy to see the appeal. As Princeton ethicist Eleanor Gordon-Smith told The Guardian, there’s something “thrilling about peeking behind the curtain into other people’s lives, hearing their weird thoughts—what they think deep down of their partners, children, friends.” The subreddit receives about 800 new scenarios every single day, creating an endless stream of drama, catharsis, and vicarious emotion for readers. Some posts become internet legends, like the tale of Jorts the orange tabby cat, whose 2021 thread became a pro-labor meme far beyond Reddit.
But beneath the entertainment, there’s a hidden tension: the rise of parasocial relationships between posters, commenters, and lurkers on AITA. A parasocial relationship is a one-sided connection in which a person feels deep familiarity or intimacy toward someone who doesn’t actually know they exist. The concept was coined in 1956 by Donald Horton and Richard Wohl to explain why TV viewers started feeling close to on-screen personalities. Today, social media and digital platforms have supercharged parasociality, making it easier for millions to feel like they “know” the strangers whose lives they read about daily.
On AITA, this dynamic can take strange forms. Commenters often develop strong emotional reactions to posters, expressing empathy, rage, or disappointment as though they were personally involved in the story. For some users, reading the daily confessions and disputes becomes a kind of ritual—checking in with familiar “characters,” rooting for underdogs, or expressing outrage at repeat offenders. The illusion of intimacy grows as commenters share advice, recount similar experiences, and, sometimes, even try to follow up on users’ ongoing dramas.
This pattern isn’t unique to AITA, but the subreddit amplifies certain tendencies. Most posts come from “throwaway” accounts, but some posters become minor celebrities within the community, with readers tracking their stories across multiple updates. When a wildly popular post gets deleted or a user vanishes, other members may express genuine grief or frustration, echoing the “parasocial breakup” phenomenon that’s been documented when a beloved TV character is killed off or a celebrity leaves the public eye.
The problem gets more tangled as the subreddit scales up. A 2023 study by researchers at Princeton used AI to analyze over 369,000 posts and 11 million comments from AITA, revealing complex social dynamics around moral judgment, empathy, and relational obligations. As the community grew from 1 million members in July 2019 to 24 million in 2025, the pressure to perform—to write for an audience, to feed their expectations, to deliver a satisfying story—rose as well. Posters have been accused of fabricating stories or exaggerating details to maximize engagement and get the “right” kind of feedback. The community sometimes turns on posters whose updates don’t meet their expectations, with accusations of lying or attention-seeking.
Commenters, meanwhile, can develop intense investment in certain posters or recurring themes. Because the interaction is fundamentally one-sided, readers project their own experiences, biases, and desires onto the anonymous narrators. The relationship feels intimate, but it’s built on incomplete information and fantasy. For some users, especially those spending hours reading and commenting, the subreddit becomes a source of companionship that blurs the boundaries between entertainment and social support.
Who gets affected by these dynamics? The answer is surprisingly broad. Posters sometimes report feeling overwhelmed or distressed by the volume and vehemence of feedback. Some users describe getting hundreds or thousands of messages after a high-profile post, experiencing everything from kindness to harassment. In a few cases, users have claimed that advice from the community influenced real-life decisions about relationships, parenting, or careers—sometimes with unintended consequences.
On the audience side, the risks range from mild to serious. Healthy parasocial relationships can provide harmless entertainment or even a sense of belonging, especially for people who feel isolated in their offline lives. But when the attachment becomes all-consuming—when users start prioritizing online drama over real-life relationships, or confusing the subreddit for genuine therapy—the line between support and unhealthy obsession can blur. As Psychology Today notes, extreme cases can interfere with daily functioning, leading individuals to neglect real-world friendships or experience emotional distress when a favorite poster disappears.
Is the criticism of AITA’s parasocial undercurrents fair? Academic researchers and journalists have offered mixed views. Some argue that parasocial connections are a natural byproduct of human brains designed for social interaction—in an environment where faces and stories are always available, we’re wired to seek out patterns and build connections, even with strangers. Others worry that the nature of AITA, with its rapid-fire judgments and anonymity, can deepen feelings of alienation, encourage performative storytelling, and foster unrealistic expectations about real-life relationships. The truth probably lies somewhere in between: the subreddit offers both social benefits and potential pitfalls, with the balance depending on how individuals engage.
Inside the community, debates rage about authenticity, responsibility, and the limits of online judgment. Some members argue that the forum is just “for fun”—a modern-day soap opera, not to be taken too seriously. Others believe the stakes are higher, especially when advice given can have real-world effects on someone’s life. The question of whether posters are telling the truth is a perennial controversy, with elaborate detective work sometimes devoted to calling out “creative writing” or “karma farming.” Meanwhile, the issue of how much empathy to extend to anonymous strangers—when the audience has only a few paragraphs of their story—remains a live discussion.
Even the mechanics of the site contribute to the problem. The most upvoted posts and comments rise to the top, shaping the narrative for millions of readers and amplifying the most emotionally charged takes. Occasional crossovers to other social media—like the Twitter account that used to repost AITA stories until 2023—spread the drama beyond Reddit and sometimes turn posters into viral sensations overnight, for better or worse.
With more than 800 new dilemmas posted daily and 24 million users, AITA has become not just a forum for judgment, but a laboratory for studying how people form connections, project their own issues onto strangers, and sometimes lose track of what’s real. Researchers from Stanford and Carnegie Mellon even used AITA data in a 2025 study to investigate how artificial intelligence models can learn the patterns of social sycophancy—showing that the site’s influence is now rippling out to shape new technologies.
So, here’s the real question: In a digital confessional this massive, where strangers become quasi-celebrities and advice can have real impact, are we building true community—or just deepening the illusion that we know each other at all?