More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
You want a ranking episode that’ll get Harry Potter fans fired up? Let’s do it. “Rank the Most Controversial” is diving into the top five most debated character choices made for Hermione Granger in the Harry Potter movies. If you’re a fan, you’ve argued about at least one of these. Let’s get right into it—counting down from number five to the number one Hermione decision that split the fandom in half.
Number 5: The Erasure of S.P.E.W. in the Movies
What happened: In the Harry Potter books, Hermione Granger founds the Society for the Promotion of Elfish Welfare, or S.P.E.W., in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. She knits hats, campaigns for house-elf rights, and spends dozens of pages battling wizard indifference to elf servitude. But in the movies, the entire S.P.E.W. plotline doesn’t exist. Not one knitted hat. Not one passionate speech about Dobby’s freedom.
Why fans argue: For some, this omission is unforgivable. Book readers say S.P.E.W. is core to Hermione’s values—her activism and her willingness to stand up for the oppressed, even when friends like Ron Weasley mock her for it. Others say it would have slowed the movies down, that moviegoers didn’t need the subplot. But the debate is about more than screentime—it’s about whether cutting S.P.E.W. gutted Hermione’s complexity and her willingness to fight for what’s right, even when she stands alone.
Number 4: The Infamous Yule Ball Dress
What happened: In Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Hermione’s big “wow” moment comes at the Yule Ball. In the book, J.K. Rowling describes her gliding down the stairs in periwinkle blue robes. In the movie, the filmmakers swapped blue for pink—a pastel, princess-style gown, dramatically different from the text.
Why fans argue: Some viewers loved the movie’s visual, but for others, this costume change was a betrayal. The argument isn’t just about color. Fans insist Hermione’s blue dress was symbolic—subtle, elegant, and true to her character. Pink, to some, felt like an attempt to make Hermione more traditionally “feminine” and dilute her nerdy, practical edge. For hardcore fans, the Yule Ball dress is shorthand for a broader debate about whether the movies softened Hermione’s book persona to fit movie tropes.
Number 3: Hermione Punches Draco Malfoy
What happened: In Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Hermione confronts Draco Malfoy and, in the movie, punches him square in the nose. In the book, she doesn’t punch him—she slaps him. The movie ramps up the violence, turning a slap into a fist, and gives the moment extra drama.
Why fans argue: Some fans cheer for movie-Hermione’s punch—it’s more satisfying, cathartic, and makes for a great GIF. But others say this decision made her more aggressive than her book counterpart. Book Hermione uses her intellect far more than her fists, and critics argue the punch was out of character. The debate boils down to whether the movies made Hermione bolder or simply less nuanced—whether it’s empowering or a cheap laugh.
Number 2: The “Ron and Hermione” Romance Shift
What happened: In the books, Hermione’s romance with Ron Weasley takes years to develop, growing from bickering to friendship to a slow-burn love. The movies condense and sometimes distort this arc. There are scenes where Hermione seems to have more chemistry, or at least more screentime, with Harry than Ron. Some movie moments—like the awkward tent dancing in Deathly Hallows Part 1—sparked rumors and endless threads about whether the movies were trying to push Harry and Hermione as a couple.
Why fans argue: This debate goes deep. “Romione” shippers say the Ron-Hermione romance is one of the series’ best payoffs, showing opposites attract and enemies can become partners. But the movies’ focus on Harry and Hermione moments led some to see a “Harmione” agenda—fueling years of shipping wars. Fans argue over whether the movies respected the source or tried to rewrite Rowling’s intended romantic pairings for mainstream appeal.
Number 1: Making Hermione the Source of All Cleverness
What happened: Throughout the movie series, Hermione Granger takes on an even bigger problem-solving role than in the books. Key magical solutions, like the Devil’s Snare in Philosopher’s Stone or brewing the Polyjuice Potion in Chamber of Secrets, are shown as Hermione’s alone. The films often give her Ron’s or even Harry’s lines—making her the go-to genius for almost every problem the trio faces.
Why fans argue: This is the most hotly debated character choice. Some fans love it—it cements Hermione as a feminist icon, gives her more time in the spotlight, and lets Emma Watson shine. Others say it’s at the expense of Ron’s character, who’s left as comic relief, and Harry’s initiative, which is sometimes diminished. The debate centers on adaptation: Did the movies elevate Hermione, or did they flatten her friends and make her less relatable by turning her into a flawless “girl who knows everything”? ScreenRant and MovieWeb both point out this trend, calling it one of the movies’ most frustrating decisions.
There’s the top five! Don’t agree with the order? Think something else deserved the number one spot? Let us know your ranking and your reasons. The Hermione debates are never over, and that’s why we love them.