More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
It all started when thousands of fans flooded Tumblr, Twitter, and Reddit with two words: “Reylo confirmed.” Suddenly, the Star Wars fandom wasn’t just debating plot holes—they were at war over whether Rey and Kylo Ren belonged together. The hashtag #Reylo trended worldwide, while an opposing group, the self-named “anti-Reylos,” pushed back with just as much energy. What made this so shocking? It wasn't just about romance. Fans accused each other of everything from romanticizing abuse to missing the “true” story, and the arguments got so heated that some users even left social media altogether.
Let’s break down who’s involved. On one side are the “Reylos,” who ship Rey and Kylo Ren—meaning they want them to be a couple, in canon or fanon. Big Reylo accounts on Tumblr like “reylo-trash” and “starwarsmakesmecry” gathered tens of thousands of followers, sharing fan art, meta-analyses, and theories. On the other side, “anti-Reylos” argued that this pairing was toxic or contradictory to the characters’ arcs. These groups became just as organized, spawning their own communities, tags, and even dedicated Discord servers. Meanwhile, a third camp—the “FinnPoe” shippers—believed the real love story was between Finn and Poe Dameron, with the ship name “Stormpilot” or “FinnPoe” appearing in tens of thousands of Ao3 fan fics.
The battle lines were drawn after the release of The Force Awakens in 2015, but things escalated dramatically after The Last Jedi in 2017. Many fans saw romantic subtext between Rey and Kylo Ren, especially after their “Force bond” scenes. The moment Adam Driver’s Kylo Ren held out his hand to Daisy Ridley’s Rey, some viewers saw it as confirmation. Others called it manipulation. The arguments exploded with The Rise of Skywalker, when the two characters finally kissed. Within hours, Twitter threads with thousands of replies dissected everything from script leaks to interviews with the cast.
Why did this get so intense? For “anti-Reylos,” the pairing represented a dangerous glamorization of abuse, with critics referencing earlier Star Wars romances to argue this ship broke franchise tradition. Some described the ship as “polarizing,” with online articles and think pieces calling it “toxic.” On the other side, Reylo fans argued that their interpretation was supported by the movies’ visual cues, and cited interviews with screenwriters suggesting that a Rey/Kylo romance was always on the table. A smaller but vocal group claimed the backlash was rooted in sexism or a refusal to accept new storylines.
Platform policy only made things messier. On Tumblr, moderators had to issue guidelines following a spike in harassment and doxxing between shipper factions. Some fan creators received threats serious enough that they deleted their work or locked it behind password-protected Ao3 pages. There were even rumors that Lucasfilm’s legal department had looked into fan content, after erotic slash fiction involving Star Wars characters started circulating, though no public takedown occurred.
The story isn’t just about Reylo. “Stormpilot” shippers—those who wanted Finn and Poe Dameron together—felt sidelined when their pairing never became canon. John Boyega and Oscar Isaac, who played Finn and Poe, publicly voiced support for FinnPoe, with Isaac saying he “hoped for more” on-screen. When The Rise of Skywalker ended without addressing this pairing, disappointment surged. Some fans accused Lucasfilm of queerbaiting, citing the tens of thousands of Stormpilot fanfics on Ao3 as evidence of pent-up demand.
Meanwhile, “Kylux” shippers—fans of Kylo Ren and Hux—wrote thousands of stories, sometimes clashing with Reylo and Stormpilot fans over which ship made more sense. In some corners, the “shipping wars” even led to review bombing of official Star Wars novels, when authors acknowledged one pairing or ignored another.
Where does this leave the fandom now? Fan communities remain highly organized, with shipping tags like #Reylo, #Stormpilot, and #Kylux still active on Tumblr, Ao3, Twitter, and Discord. Some creators have re-emerged, sharing content under pseudonyms to avoid targeted harassment. Others say the wars have left permanent scars. Yet, new ships keep forming—like “Wolfwren,” after the appearance of Sabine Wren and Shin Hati in the Ahsoka series.
And here’s the unresolved question: Will Lucasfilm ever directly address the shipping wars—or will future Star Wars media continue fueling these debates, one ambiguous glance at a time?