More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
My Hero Academia, created by Kōhei Horikoshi, exploded in popularity after its manga debut in Weekly Shōnen Jump on July 7, 2014. The story follows Izuku Midoriya, called Deku, who’s born without a “Quirk”—the term for superpowers in the series—but dreams of becoming a hero. By April 2024, the manga had over 100 million copies in circulation, a number that places it among the best-selling manga series of all time. Its anime adaptation, produced by the studio Bones, ran for eight seasons from April 2016 to December 2025, and the franchise has spawned four animated films, three spin-off manga series, and multiple video games for platforms like Nintendo Switch, PlayStation, and Xbox.
Fans love My Hero Academia for its blend of superhero action and emotional storytelling. It’s a world where 80% of humanity has some kind of Quirk, but for the remaining 20%, life is very different. That focus on perseverance, teamwork, and the idea that anyone could be a hero—regardless of background or ability—is a big reason for the fandom’s wide appeal. The series has won awards like the Sugoi Japan Award and the Harvey Award for Best Manga.
But for all the love, there’s a darker current running through the community: gatekeeping. Fans often debate who qualifies as a “real” My Hero Academia fan. Some longtime followers criticize newcomers, especially those who joined after the 2016 anime release, arguing that new fans lack “true” knowledge of the series or don’t respect its origins in the manga. This tension is visible in online forums, social media, and even at conventions where cosplayers can feel pressured to prove their knowledge of the lore or justify their interpretation of characters.
Gatekeeping in the My Hero Academia fandom didn’t start overnight. The explosive growth of the franchise, especially after the first anime season aired, changed the makeup of the community. Early manga readers, sometimes called “OG fans,” had spent years with the series before it became a mainstream hit. When the anime adaptation brought in millions of new fans, the sudden influx led to culture clashes. Some OG fans worried that the flood of newcomers would dilute the “true” spirit of the series or reduce appreciation for Horikoshi’s original work. As new fans engaged with popular characters like Katsuki Bakugo or Shoto Todoroki, debates erupted over character motivations, shipping (pairing characters in fan works), and interpretations of major plot points.
The rise of cosplay and online content amplified these tensions. Greater visibility sometimes meant harsher scrutiny. Cosplayers who chose less-popular characters—or interpreted them in non-canonical ways—reported being challenged by others to justify their choices or recite facts from the series. In some cases, fans who only watched the anime, or started after a particular season, were dismissed as “fake fans” by segments of the community.
The people most affected by this gatekeeping are often those who came to the series through the anime, international fans, or younger viewers who might not have access to the original Japanese manga. The franchise’s official English release by Viz Media began in August 2015, but lagged behind the Japanese serialization. As a result, those who followed along in English or discovered the series through platforms like Viz’s Weekly Shonen Jump app were sometimes accused of being “lesser” fans. Social media platforms like Tumblr, where My Hero Academia consistently ranked among the most-discussed anime and manga, became battlegrounds for these debates, with posts dissecting who got to call themselves a “real” fan.
Is this criticism fair? On one hand, long-term fans might feel a sense of ownership after years of investment—especially as the franchise’s global footprint grew. The series’ world-building and character development invite deep analysis, and those who followed plot arcs like the Paranormal Liberation War or the reveal of Dabi as Endeavor’s son may take pride in their close reading. But on the other hand, the very themes that Horikoshi emphasized—perseverance, teamwork, and the notion that anyone can become a hero—stand in direct contrast to exclusion. Horikoshi once said he created a world where anyone, regardless of background or ability, could achieve greatness, and he specifically called out the importance of even “Quirkless” individuals like Deku, who triumphs through hard work.
The debate isn’t just about who read the manga first or who has the largest collection of character merchandise. It also touches on cultural and linguistic divides. My Hero Academia was released simultaneously in English and Japanese starting in January 2019 via Manga Plus, but before that, non-Japanese speakers had to rely on fan translations, which varied in quality and availability. The global popularity poll “World Best Hero,” announced by Shueisha in August 2024, was the first manga character poll to be held worldwide, but even that led to debates over who could or should participate.
Fanworks and shipping culture add another layer. Characters like Izuku Midoriya, Bakugo, and Todoroki occupy several of the top spots in global cosplay and fan art rankings. But disagreements over which romantic pairings are “valid” or whether certain interpretations are canon can spark intense arguments. In 2019, Izuku Midoriya was the most popular anime and manga character on Tumblr, and seven My Hero Academia characters made Tumblr’s top 10 list in 2020, fueling even more discussion—and sometimes exclusion—over how characters should be portrayed.
Some community members argue that gatekeeping actually harms the franchise. As My Hero Academia became a global phenomenon—with over 50 million manga copies sold by 2021, and its theatrical films like “Two Heroes” premiering at events such as Anime Expo in Los Angeles—it attracted fans from across cultures and generations. Critics of gatekeeping say that trying to police entry points or enforce “correct” ways of engaging with the material contradicts the values the series promotes.
Others counter that some level of curation is necessary to preserve the depth and nuance of the story. The manga’s final volume, released in December 2024 with 38 pages of new content, brought discussions about canon and headcanon (fan interpretations) into sharper focus. Fans debate whether newcomers who only watch the films or play the video games—like “My Hero One’s Justice” and “Ultra Rumble”—can fully appreciate plot arcs that span dozens of manga chapters.
The community is still divided over where to draw the line. Is it enough to enjoy the anime, or does one have to read all 42 manga volumes, including spin-offs like “Vigilantes” and “Team-Up Missions”? Are cosplayers required to know character backstories, or is it enough to simply love a costume? Should fan art and shipping be policed for “accuracy,” or is imagination part of the fun? These are the questions that animate message boards, social media threads, and real-life conventions.
One thing is clear: My Hero Academia’s world is built on the idea that anyone can be a hero—with or without a Quirk.