More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
What does it look like when the internet’s “front page” just…vanishes? Picture this: you wake up, log onto Reddit for your usual caffeine fix of memes, breaking news, or cat videos—and instantly hit a wall. Your favorite communities are locked down, the comment threads are gone, and the usual chaos has been replaced with digital silence. That’s exactly what happened during the Great Reddit Blackout of 2023, when over 7,000 subreddits—some of the biggest on the site—suddenly went dark in a protest that would shake the core of the internet’s most unruly platform.
So, why did Reddit’s massive hive mind go on strike? In April 2023, Reddit announced something that would send shockwaves through its millions of users: the company would start charging for API access. Since 2008, Reddit’s API had been free, powering everything from third-party apps like Apollo to essential moderation tools that helped volunteers keep the chaos in check. Suddenly, this free pipeline was going behind a steep paywall.
Christian Selig, the developer behind Apollo, went public on May 31 with a number that stunned the community: $12,000 for every 50 million API requests. To keep Apollo running, he’d have to pay up to $20 million a year. That’s not a typo—$20 million, for a single app. Selig said simply, “I could not pay Reddit’s pricing and was unsure how to even charge it.” Other developers of popular third-party Reddit apps like RIF and Relay echoed the same story. For many, this meant a total shutdown.
The immediate cause for Reddit’s new charges? CEO Steve Huffman argued that AI companies, including those behind tools like ChatGPT, were scraping Reddit’s data for free to train their models. Huffman said, “The Reddit corpus of data is really valuable, but we don’t need to give all of that value to some of the largest companies in the world for free.” But the backlash wasn’t just from tech companies or app builders—ordinary Redditors and moderators were furious.
On June 12, 2023, the protest began. Moderators—who are unpaid volunteers—flipped a digital switch. Subreddits with millions of followers, including r/pics, r/funny, and r/science, went private or restricted posting. The blackout caused such a shockwave that Reddit itself suffered temporary outages. The initial plan was a 48-hour protest. But when Reddit’s leadership remained defiant, thousands of communities kept themselves dark indefinitely.
Reddit administrators issued warnings: reopen your subreddits, or we’ll replace you as moderators. Some communities complied and reopened. Others doubled down, keeping themselves dark for weeks. A few found creative new ways to protest. Users of r/pics and r/gifs, after reopening, voted to post only about comedian John Oliver—filling the front page with his face as a form of digital picketing.
Other subreddits escalated by marking themselves as “not safe for work,” or NSFW—even though their usual content was pretty tame. This disrupted Reddit’s advertising revenue, since ads can’t run on NSFW communities. Reddit’s response was swift: it removed entire moderation teams and replaced them with new users who would follow the site’s directive.
During the blackout, the collaborative art event r/place returned, and the canvas became a digital battleground. Protesters used pixels to spell out “Fuck spez”—a direct dig at CEO Steve Huffman’s Reddit username—and even drew the site’s mascot, Snoo, under a guillotine labeled “Huffman.” These messages were visible to millions, an unmissable sign of how deeply the protest had penetrated Reddit culture.
The actual changes went ahead anyway. On June 30, the new API pricing took effect, and third-party apps like Apollo, Sync, RIF, and BaconReader shut down, leaving only a handful willing or able to switch to a subscription model. Apps with a focus on accessibility, like RedReader and Dystopia, received specific exemptions, but details were sparse—causing further confusion. Some moderators, including those with disabilities, said that Reddit’s own tools remained so clunky that they couldn’t moderate on mobile anymore.
As the protest dragged on, Reddit administrators took even stronger actions. On July 21, Reddit forcibly took over r/malefashionadvice, a popular style community, using an account named “ModCodeofConduct.” New moderators, often with little experience or knowledge of the specific communities, were installed. One former moderator described how their team had backgrounds in art history, able to recognize authentic content—but the replacements seemed to care only about compliance.
The blackout’s ripple effects spread far beyond Reddit’s own backyard. Minecraft’s developer, Mojang Studios, publicly quit posting game updates on Reddit, saying it would only return if the company changed its API rules. Google, which had long relied on Reddit for high-quality user-generated answers to niche questions, suddenly saw its search results degrade. In an all-hands meeting, a Google senior vice president admitted that users were “not quite happy” with search after the Reddit blackout.
Reddit’s leadership maintained that the company needed to “be fairly paid” to continue supporting high-usage apps and that its hosting costs ran into the multi-millions. Spokesperson Tim Rathschmidt said the new API pricing was based on usage levels “comparable to our own costs.” But many developers, moderators, and users challenged whether those figures truly reflected the platform’s actual expenses or just a new drive for profitability ahead of an initial public offering.
The story didn’t end with the protest. In June, the ransomware group BlackCat claimed to have stolen 80 gigabytes of Reddit data in a security breach, threatening to release it unless Reddit paid $4.5 million and reversed the API changes. Reddit confirmed that BlackCat was behind a February security incident but did not accede to their demands.
Columnists and analysts began to draw a bigger picture. Cory Doctorow, who coined the term “enshittification,” described Reddit’s moves as part of a larger trend: platforms start off by offering something great for users, then shift value to business partners, and finally drain both sides to maximize profits—often at the expense of the very communities that made them successful. By July, “enshittification” had become the American Dialect Society’s Word of the Year, propelled in part by the Great Reddit Blackout itself.
Reddit’s user numbers remained massive: as of 2025, the site boasted 121.4 million daily active users. But trust between Reddit’s leadership and its moderator community had been damaged, perhaps permanently. Even as some subreddits returned to business as usual, many users reported a sense of loss—saying the blackout marked the end of an era when volunteers shaped the site’s identity.
Here’s the twist: during the blackout, Google Search results for topics like The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom suddenly got worse because Reddit content was harder to find. Developers, researchers, and even casual users all felt the absence. The blackout didn’t just affect Reddit—it left a visible hole in the wider internet’s ability to organize, search, and share knowledge. And for some, the real mystery remains: what happens the next time a platform’s users decide to pull the plug on the digital town square?