More from this creator
Other episodes by Kitty Cat.
More like this
If you liked this, try these.
Transcript
The full episode, in writing.
Today, we're diving into “The Dark Side of Animal Crossing’s Raymond Craze.” If you’ve spent any time in the world of Animal Crossing: New Horizons, you already know what makes it special—relaxed island life, adorable villagers, and the freedom to design your own paradise. But for many players, the arrival of one particular cat in 2020 changed the game’s social dynamics in ways nobody expected.
Raymond, an anthropomorphic gray cat with striking heterochromia—one green eye, one amber—debuted in Animal Crossing: New Horizons for the Nintendo Switch in 2020. He quickly became the most sought-after villager in the series. Part of his appeal came from details: his businesslike outfit, round glasses, a tuft of blonde hair, and the fact that he’s the only smug cat character in the game. In the Japanese version, he’s known as Jack (ジャック, Jakku). Players loved not just his looks, but also his personality—pleasant yet quick to brag, and willing to wear a maid outfit on request, which resonated with many in the LGBTQ community.
The real turning point for Raymond’s popularity was the context of his release. Animal Crossing: New Horizons hit the market in March 2020, just as the COVID-19 pandemic forced millions globally into lockdown. The game soared in popularity, selling over 30 million copies by the end of its first year, as reported by Nintendo. The pandemic transformed Animal Crossing into a social lifeline: players visited each other’s islands, hosted virtual birthday parties, and built communities online. Within weeks, Raymond’s unique charm made him a viral sensation. Fan art, memes, and cosplay featuring Raymond flooded social media. Tumblr, Twitter, and even YouTube saw Raymond’s image go viral, especially when videos showed him performing in a maid outfit while playing the tambourine.
But the love for Raymond quickly brought a new dynamic—and a darker edge—to the cozy world of Animal Crossing. Because Raymond wasn’t initially available through Amiibo cards or figures, the only way to recruit him was through chance encounters or by acquiring him from other players. He could show up at the campsite, be found on Mystery Island Tours, or appear when a villager was moving out. This rarity, combined with his popularity, made him the hottest commodity in the game’s trading scene.
What happened next was an explosion of high-stakes trading. Players began offering massive amounts of in-game currency, called bells, or the coveted Nook Miles Tickets, to secure Raymond. Some went further, spending real money—there are reports of Raymond being listed on eBay for as much as $1,000, far above the cost of the actual video game and console combined. On fan-made websites like Nookazon and nook.market, Raymond became the number one most-requested villager, at times accounting for half of all trade requests. A meme grew around the phrase “Raymond in boxes,” referring to the short period when a villager is packed to move and available for trade. Demand was so intense that scams and price gouging became widespread.
As this black market for villagers took over the Animal Crossing community, a wave of backlash began. Many players criticized the trading frenzy as undermining the game’s intended spirit—one of friendship, relaxation, and community. The atmosphere shifted from neighborly cooperation to ruthless capitalism. Some players intentionally sent Raymond to “the void”—letting him move out without anyone else recruiting him—just to annoy the fandom. Others posted outrageous trade requests as a form of protest or satire. The phenomenon sparked debates about fairness: was it okay for some players to profit from the scarcity of a digital cat, or did it create an exclusive, elitist culture that locked out newcomers and younger players?
These questions split the community. For some, the trading economy was a fun challenge, adding new layers of strategy and social interaction. For others, it felt unfair and even exploitative. Some accused high-end traders of gatekeeping, making popular villagers inaccessible to anyone unwilling—or unable—to pay enormous sums of bells or real money. Reports of scams also surfaced, with players taking currency or items and failing to deliver Raymond. This contributed to a sense of distrust and frustration, especially for younger or less experienced fans.
The debates reached their peak from 2020 to 2021, as the pandemic continued and New Horizons remained one of the world’s most popular games. Criticism also extended to Nintendo, with some saying the lack of Amiibo cards for new villagers, including Raymond, was a design flaw that fueled the “black market.” Others pointed out that the scarcity and trading economy were inevitable in a game where digital characters could become status symbols.
Inside the community, opinions remained divided. Some fans called for reforms, such as banning real-money trading and introducing better trading protections to prevent scams. Others set up their own initiatives to disrupt the black market, like YouTuber PokéNinja, who distributed Raymond to anyone who wanted him, free of charge, using save editors. This directly challenged the exclusivity of the trading system and was justified, according to PokéNinja, by the desire to keep Animal Crossing fun and accessible for all players, especially children whose parents could not afford to pay for a virtual villager.
Yet, for every critic, there were just as many who enjoyed the thrill of the hunt or the opportunity to profit from a high-demand asset. For some, owning Raymond became a badge of honor, a mark of dedication and luck. Others felt left out or frustrated by the apparent elitism, with some saying they didn’t “deserve” Raymond because they weren’t rich in bells or Nook Miles Tickets.
The debates also spilled over into other corners of Animal Crossing’s fandom. The manga adaptation of New Horizons featured Raymond with a completely different, even more narcissistic personality, amplifying his divisive status. His appearance in official merchandise—including stickers, plush dolls, and magnets—kept the character in the spotlight long after the trading craze peaked.
As of the latest reporting, community discussions about the ethics of villager trading, exclusivity, and the impact of digital scarcity are still ongoing. Some players want Nintendo to take a stronger stance, perhaps by banning real-money trades or making rare villagers more accessible. Others still cherish the competitive, social edge that trading brought to the game during a time of global isolation.
So, is the criticism of the Raymond craze fair? That depends on which side of the digital fence you’re on. For some, it’s a story of creative community engagement and resourcefulness. For others, it’s a cautionary tale about what happens when a cozy escape turns into a high-stakes marketplace.
The Animal Crossing community continues to debate where to draw the line between fun, fairness, and exploitation. Should Nintendo intervene more strongly, or is the market-driven chaos just another layer of player-driven storytelling? And as new characters join the franchise, will the next Raymond spark the same frenzy—or has the community learned from its wildest trading days?